I think this one would be up there as well.
The chemistry between the judges here is a prime example of why the channel seven reboot isn’t working this year.
6 Likes
Problem is these shows are too overproduced and scripted these days. The public would rather watch something real and authentic, even if it is a bit daggy.
7 Likes
Like Married at First Sight? Very “real and authentic”… 
But agree that these sorts of talent shows have been way overproduced and scripted. Well, in recent years anyway.
I will tune in tonight’s show to see how the pre-recorded “live performance shows” come out in the airing. Hopefully with 12 singers, it will be sharp and to the point, and no need to see many previous performances or see many back-stories.
3 Likes
Looks recorded to me
This week’s theme is No.1 hits.
Two contestants will be eliminated on Monday’s show. Each week, the four judges will get to see one another contestant from going home.
Carmen Smith is still vocal coach until the grand final.
1 Like
It was. Last night.
4 Likes
Man that Meghan Trainer is doing my head in 
3 Likes
“LIVE aedt” so they’re flat out lying to the audience on this?
2 Likes
Well there’s another easy way to lose more viewers IMO.
5 Likes
4/4 boring. 
Edit - Amali the first act of the night to be half decent.
And now we have a Farmer Wants a Wife preview as part of the Idol show 
5 Likes
Meghan: “Oh my gawwwwd. You’re soooo young” to all four contestants so far. Great feedback.!
Now a Farmer Wants A Wife ad within the show. Way too drag Idol even more…
4 Likes
Seriously? 
2 Likes
Why is it so hard for Seven to do live shows properly? Back in the X Factor days they did it so we’ll and everything just felt like a good ol’ talent show that produced stars.
Now everything is just too nice. AGT, The Voice, this.
8 Likes
This is cringe asf 
3 Likes
My ears are bleeding.
2 Likes
Then turn it off. You’re clearly not enjoying the show. Don’t watch it then lol.
2 Likes
I’m enjoying the show. I’m not enjoying the performances. That’s allowed.
Also, last time I checked making comments about the show as it’s airing is also allowed.
8 Likes
I didnt say it wasn’t.
It’s just confusing that you’re enjoying the show but not the performances. I don’t really understand how that’s possible when the show IS the performances.
Umm it’s quite easy. I like the format. I like the concept. I like the nostalgia. I like the judges. I like the hosts. I like some of the contestants.
Just for me, so far tonight, I’m yet to see someone I’d want to vote for.
What is it that doesn’t make sense about that? Am I supposed to be all OMG THEY ARE ALL SO GOOD - when they literally aren’t?!
And it’s another ‘it’s a no from me’ for Harry.
9 Likes
No, I agree. They’re all terrible except Josh, Amali and the young girls.
I think half of them shouldn’t be there and do not understand for the life of me how this is our Top 12.
2 Likes