It is not nonsensical, it’s already a thing in many areas, on both TV and radio.
Also regarding the advertising, it would be Adelaide and Perth that retains local advertising, because advertisers are still buying spots on those networks. In the regional areas, it’s a rather different story.
Apparently, there are far fewer advertisers on NBN Northern NSW than that of some Seven and Ten stations, and then online, billboards and local radio. Most of the ads on the stations are national buys. You’re more likely to see heaps of local advertising starting from midnight until 6am in the morning on Seven at the very least, though they’ll probably be repeated countless times.
As for this whole statewide thing, this is essentially what happened in the past.
Firstly, WIN News firstly consolidated all their bulletins to Wollongong, then they starting axing some of them, and then they converted most of their local bulletins in Regional VIC/QLD into single statewide editions, which saw the lost of jobs in the regional areas where they used to have a seperate local news bulletin. The whole statewide WIN News thing began on 1st July 2021.
Secondly, people have also speculated statewide stuff for radio too. Many have suggested that Hit Network stations (in their current form) should be turned into repeaters of their respective capital city stations. Essentially put, for example, SCA decided to firstly scrap local breakfast shows in Regional VIC/NSW/QLD/SA. Then they brought in a Albury radio show to take over the reigns. Then SCA decided to scrap that Albury radio show that was rather doing well in those areas, and are now having the Regional VIC breakfast show come out of Tasmania. The slow and painful death of the Hit Network. Most stuff is syndicated nowadays on their networks, and the same can be said for television.
What next? Axe that radio show and to top it all off, have Regional Victorians turn to Fifi, Fev and Nick from Fox FM in Melbourne? Might as well name them their respective metropolitan names and carry metropolitan programming. SCA are looking to save money instead of putting their efforts into giving talented radio stars a chance to host a breakfast show, or even the weekday and weekend slots.
VIC for example
FOX 101.9 Melbourne
FOX 104.9 The Border
FOX 91.9 Bendigo
FOX 96.9 Shepparton
FOX 99.5 Sunraysia
The same could happen also in NSW, QLD, SA and WA, potentially.
This is just a rough sketch of what could happen to the TV networks (and Hit Network radio stations) in the future. These plans are not confirmed, so do take this with a grain of salt.
And in response to all the criticism regarding this idea, here’s a much more eased list, now retaining some regional stations.
Seven
7 Sydney
7 Melbourne
7 Brisbane
7 Adelaide
7 Perth
7 Gold Coast
7 Regional QLD
Nine
9 Sydney
9 Melbourne
9 Brisbane
9 Adelaide
9 Perth
9 Gold Coast
9 Northern NSW
Ten
10 Sydney
10 Melbourne
10 Brisbane
10 Adelaide
10 Perth
Outside of those areas, it would essentially just be the capital city channels. If all programming on 7 Ballarat, Bendigo, Shepparton, Traralgon and Mildura is just all Melbourne programming for example, might as well just turn them into repeaters for 7 Melbourne? That would perhaps make a bit more sense, as some residents in Ballarat or Colac, for example, who are being served the local Ballarat signals, are choosing to receive the Melbourne signals instead. Some Traralgon residents are receiving the Melbourne channels too, instead of the local channels. It’s a sign of the times.