Transport heavyweights Rod Hook, Luigi Rossi, John Hill back calls for passenger rail in the Adelaide Hills
A state-government commissioned report into Hills transport needs has been slammed as misleading by industry heavyweights who claim data had been cherry picked to suit the Liberal Government’s anti-rail stance.
Lydia Kellner
February 12, 2022
A report into the transport needs of Hills residents has been slammed as misleading by industry experts who claim data had been “cherry picked” to suit the state government’s anti-rail stance.
Former Planning, Transport and Infrastructure boss Rod Hook, transport heavy hitter Luigi Rossi and SA Transport Action Group Chair John Hill have called on the government to consider further research into passenger rail after a study by Infrastructure SA claimed it would not meet consumer needs.
The study indicated money would be better spent in expanding existing bus services and claimed travel by rail would take over 70 minutes from Mt Barker to the city.
However, independent research conducted by SATAG and Mr Rossi shows travel by rail would take no more than 50 minutes.
A time estimate has been backed by former Australian National Rail engineer and Mt Barker local Douglas McCarty.
The trio has also questioned the study’s $250m cost estimate to run a service on the existing Australian Rail Track Corporation line, stating it could be done for $150m.
Mr Rossi said the only way to settle the dispute was to conduct a trial.
“One thing we want to be very clear on is, stop cherry picking data and let’s get a detailed assessment done before a final decision is made,” he said.
“So before we jump onto this bandwagon that rail is not a solution, let’s do a trial. Let’s run a train down to the city and let’s see how long it will take.”
Mr Hook, who currently serves on the board of Infrastructure Australia, said passenger rail needed to be on the cards to service Mt Barker’s growing transport needs.
“No one is saying that we need to spend a billion dollars on rail in the next budgets but the reality is that there’s an election and needs to be on the agenda,” Mr Hook said.
“If you want to do a short term solution, to show rail works, buy some decent rolling stock.
“I believe this would demonstrate that you can get down in the morning in about 50 minutes which is the same time you spend in a bus or longer if there’s congestion or an accident on the South East Freeway.”
Transport Minister Corey Wingard would not comment on whether he’d consider running a trial on the existing rail line.
“ISA engaged independent engineering firm WSP to conduct a thorough review and technical assessment of all rail options,” he said.
“They determined a new heavy rail corridor would cost around $6b and using the existing ARTC line would have a travel time of at least 70 minutes to the Adelaide Railway Station,” Mr Wingard told The Advertiser.