Reflecting on the coverage, there are some improvements on Seven’s coverage, but there are also some flaws as well.
Firstly, basing the coverage in the host city was overall a good move, although Seven didn’t go to Tokyo in 2021 for obvious reasons. They also had a good line-up of hosts in James Bracey, Dylan Alcott, Nick McArdle, and Sam McClure (the latter two on 9Gem), and it was nice to see some of the less popular sports feature (climbing a notable one). Matt Thompson on swimming was also an improvement from Basil Zemplis, and Gerard Whateley was a good substitute for Bruce McAveny on the track. Even Mark Taylor at some points surprised me as fairly decent on the diving, and Eddie McGuire was actually very good on overnights, and did an outstanding job during the closing ceremony (apart from missing the entrance of the Aussie athletes).
The opening ceremony coverage however, was a bit of mess, however, that is probably down to the fact that the commentators were out underneath a tarp in the rain, which is probably why they weren’t able to read notes while watching monitors, etc. Ally and Karl were also probably not the best choices either. At least Nine made up for it in the end with a decent closing ceremony commentary.
However, one of the biggest flaws is Nine delaying events well after they happen, either for primetime viewing, or because of other events. However, they still acted like it was about to happen live, when it wasn’t. This was particularly noticeable with the track heats. Also there were occasions when 9Gem and Nine would air the same thing, either live or a minute or two behind. Was fine though when Nine just crossed to events when Aussies were on, while 9Gem showed the whole thing. Someone at Nine though clearly has an obsession with golf, given how 9Gem would stay with it for extended periods, and miss some Aussie moments because of it. If they were happy to show things later on delay, they could’ve just shown us the Australian’s when they were up. Also when they negotiate the next NRL rights (if they get them), they should put a clause in that says that the Olympics should remain on the main channel.
Another flaw in the coverage is some questionable host choices. It’s very clear IMO that Leila McKinnon, even though she is barely seen on Nine these days, was only there because her husband is a former Nine CEO, and they needed to give her something to justify her contract. Was very obvious that Dylan, and Bracey in the final few days, were doing the heavy lifting during their sessions - though she did do a decent job for the closing ceremony. Alision Langdon also underperformed IMO, however, she was slightly better than McKinnon. Sylvia Jeffreys is also another random name who they selected - presumably to give her something to do while Today Extra was off air.
An additional flaw is picking news people to do the hosting overseas - they clearly wanted Karl, Sarah and Ally back in Aus today for the return of their shows, so they flew them out early, and changed the hosting rosters around - including using Roz Kelly, who IMO was underutilized. Clearly Nine don’t have much faith in the Weekend Today team to fill in on weekdays given their ratings, unlike the Weekend Sunrise hosts who regularly fill in on weekdays (although Clint was in Paris).
The Today in Paris format was also underwhelming. I understand that since it’s the Olympics, they want to show highlights, replays etc, however, it was a bit flat. Sure, show the shorter events (swimming, relays) in full, but the longer replays should’ve been cutdown to 5-10 minutes max. Also could’ve helped, especially on weekdays, to have the news updates every 30 minutes like the normal show. The format they were doing in the leadup to Paris is a good example of what it could’ve looked like, or NBC Today’s format. Overall it felt like it lacked energy, especially from Karl and Sarah.
News coverage was decent, with a good selection of reporters - however, in Adelaide (and presumably Perth), the 30 minute format each night felt like they had an in-depth look at the games, but rushed through the rest of the days news before sport and weather, and even there, there was a lack of local content (although that seems to be a daily issue for Nine Adelaide). They did however prioritize certain stories in front of the Olympic coverage (Interest Rates announcement, State Opposition Leader resigning, etc)
However, there are still more positives, like Stan offering coverage from international broadcasters (though would have benefited from having a US broadcaster like NBC or CBC, or the BBC), as well as 9Now having all the world feeds available to stream for free, with Stan having them in 4k as well.
Also kudos to Nine’s publicity team, whose graphics and promotion of the games, from the daily promos, to the high quality photo and promo shoots, has far exceeded Seven’s efforts in recent years.
Overall, Nine has put in a very good effort, however, there are still many improvements. Though it should be noted that this is Nine’s first Olympics since London 2012, which was very poor. Hopefully they do a good review at their coverage, and improve on their good effort so far in LA 2028 (and in the 2026 Winter Olympics, and the upcoming Paralympics).
Am I being overcritical? Maybe. I will admit that I am slightly bias towards Seven (and to the ABC). Will everyone here agree with me? Probably not, but there are some points that I have reiterated that have been mentioned multiple times over the past few weeks.
Special thanks should go to @TV.Cynic who will now be able to sleep after almost a month of updating us on schedule changes, channel changes, as well as getting us caps and drinking an unlimited amount of coffee. Also forgot to do this at the time, but thanks to @cmo for providing some insight into the artistic portions of the opening ceremony, and at times, doing a better job than Nine’s own commentators.
Fuck I’ve got too much spare time on my hands 