Who would you prefer?
Like to host: Deb Knight, David Campbell, Tim Davies, Charles Croucher, Stevie Jacobs
Prefer: Tony Jones, Ross Greenwood, Ben Fordham, Tim Gilbert, Camerin Williams.
1 Like
Apart from David Campbell…what a dire list.
3 Likes
Brenton and Georgie or Sylvia?
I think it’s great for Brenton to be able to host. He has shown previously that he is quite capable, having presented over last summer. He may also help to connect to viewers in SA which could also help to boost viewership for the local 6pm news in Adelaide.
And just slightly off topic, he is definitely an asset to Nine having once been the weather presenter in Adelaide (replacing the talented Keith Martyn) and upon NEC gaining control of the station, he was bumped up to the presenters chair. So somebody has seen his potential. And I’d daresay, the bigger bosses back east have also taken note.
4 Likes
Probably why talk of Karl leaving Today has always been taken with a grain of salt, there’s no one waiting in the wings to take over.
Look at Sunrise’s succession planning,Sam Armytage got the job when Mel Doyle left but it could have easily been Natalie Barr or Kylie Gillies. If Koch was to leave, there’s Basil, AOK could easily come back into the fold, Larry Emdur as well someone like Mark Beretta.
Today hasn’t planned nearly as well and often their on air line up appears like a mish-mash.
The fact Ragless is being given a three week stint indicates they seem to still have no certainty over Karl’s natural successor.
6 Likes
Great analysis. Sunrise always seems to have a team of superior backups, whereas Today always seems to be fronted by a bunch of randoms for fill-in (some are good, some not so). If presenters are a main reason for viewers tuning in then Sunrise have definitely hit the right notes (especially when fill-ins present).
2 Likes
Really?
Brenton has shown that he is a very bland news anchor, let alone a presenter at breakfast. He seems to have little personality or opinions and is not controversial enough to generate headlines for the show. Perhaps his best trait is that is his affable/nice?
When Today’s ratings are dire, they REALLY need to look beyond a little cross-promotion for Adelaide’s 6pm News. Even the suggestion that by having Brenton on MIGHT boost their Adelaide audience is ridiculous. Melbourne and Sydney are (should be) of their concern at the moment and getting a wooden and unfamiliar personality is not advisable and those viewers will only join the drones switching over to Sunrise and News Breakfast.
Perhaps that accentuates how bad of a choice Brenton is… You don’t like Deb Knight?
As was evident when Lisa quit. They had no idea what to do; Deb Knight had never co-hosted alongside Karl before.
Sunrise, as you say, do it so well and it even appears that Nat will take over from Koch in the coming years. Moreover, the way they organise their team’s annual leave is done with such precision that it ensures viewers are left with some familiar faces.
She’s perfectly suited to newsreader but I’d rather her than Sylvia.
1 Like
Allison is back hosting with Peter with Mark Burrows reading news and Alice Monfries presenting the weather this weekend.
2 Likes
This may interest some of you… https://decidertv.com/page/2018/12/1/interview-karl-stefanovic-opens-up-on-ratings-pressure-mexico-wedding-and-nearly-quitting-today
2 Likes
The Christmas break allows the TODAY family including Georgie Gardner, Sylvia Jefferys, Tim Gilbert and Richard Wilkins to travel to Mexico where they will attend Karl’s wedding to his new love, Jasmine Yarbrough;
I find this interesting. Something you would never see mentioned in the DailyFail, for obvious reasons.
2 Likes
All I got from that is that all of their team will be away for 1-2 weeks! 
Wouldn’t it be interesting if the team led by Brenton and Deb achieve higher ratings than Karl/ Georgie/ Sylvia/ Tim. Could be a perfect opportunity to test for a complete revamp of the show.
3 Likes
No. I know it is the end of the rating seasons, but that should not mean everyone gets to go on a 2 month (hyperbole) break. They have the potential of attracting newer audiences, especially with their summer of Tennis, who will not return if they continue to produce a second-rate show over summer every year.
IF they like the team, and discover that they are not permanent, they will switch back at the start of the ratings year.
What Today needed to do is split Karl and Georgie’s leave, just as Sunrise have done for almost 10 years, so that people know that is who is hosting Today ( seems they are trying to deceive them actually ATM). The show needs consistency and familiarity and a commitment from the network that Georgie and Karl are here to stay. @David You are going to say that this won’t work, but Seven News Brisbane is an apt example and now they are number 1.
Haha. You would be lucky to see any changes when they return in late January, let alone in December!
I didn’t say anything about making changes in December?
I meant that if this summer team is successful that they would have an option if the future of a change of team knowing that they have people to replace the current bunch that viewers like.
You know it won’t happen, right? Lara and Brenton have both filled in last year (the latter never filled-in for Karl all year. It seems he is the only one they can get for summer). Deb Knight was hosting for three months, yet they gave the position to Georgie.
I thought you were talking about set/graphics. Sorry.
2 Likes
That’s why l like summer fill in presenters/newsreaders some years as a viewer you discover someone who has talent, of course the networks are also testing who works well and has potential for a future full time role within the networks.
5 Likes
The show creates a promo for Brenton’s appearance but hasn’t made one for the regular team since Jan 22? I don’t get them sometimes.
3 Likes
I expect ratings to hit new lows over the summer. For too long they have treated their audience with contempt and it is finally catching up with them.
The focus over the next fortnight should have been on maintaining as steady a ship as possible. It would have been a great opportunity to demonstrate that the show is about more than just one person but instead they are doing the opposite.
4 Likes